Author Topic: Internal or External Filter in A Tank? (Read 11059 times) 6 replies

Wild Rover · « **on:** October 27, 2014, 09:03:04 AM »

Hi

I have a Fluval Roma 200 which came with a U4 internal filter which works very well and is virtually silent. I was playing around with the stocking calculator and if I entered the fish I want with the U4 it showed the stocking level at 85%. However, if I change the filter on the calculator to an over sized external (thinking Fluval 306) the stocking level drops to 47%! I realise the filtration is better and the volume of water increases a bit but does it really make that much difference?

Would you make the swop? I have five reservations

1) I live in a first floor apartment and I have worries about an external filter flooding
2) How noisy are they?
3) Would I need a lot of space behind the tank to set it up?
4) Would increasing the stock just look too crowded and if I didn't would the 306 be overkill?
5) Would the established filter cartridges from the U4 fit into the 306?

Any advice appreciated, don't feel you have to answer all of the points - If you can offer an opinion on any of them it would be great. Thanks

daniel_james_taylor · « **Reply #1 on:** October 27, 2014, 11:36:20 AM »

Hey wild rover,

I have an aqua manta eco 100 (200L) aquarium and use an external filter. It came with an external EFX 200filter rated up to 200L however I upgraded it to the next model up EFX 300 (300L).

1) I live in a first floor apartment and I have worries about an external filter flooding - I haven't had any issues with this, other members may have better advice on this?
2) How noisy are they? Mine is quieter than some internals I have in other tanks. This can vary brand to brand and the cheaper models can be noisier.
3) Would I need a lot of space behind the tank to set it up? Mine sits inside the tank cabinet. Is you tank on a stand?
4) Would increasing the stock just look too crowded and if I didn't would the 306 be overkill? What stock have you already got? You could displace the 306's flow using long spray bars so your fish aren't fighting a concentrated current.
5) Would the established filter cartridges from the U4 fit into the 306? I cut up filter media from another aquarium and the ceramic media just fitter into the baskets within the external filter.

I hope this helps a little and I'm sure other members may have some ideas too

Wild Rover · « **Reply #2 on:** October 27, 2014, 12:41:32 PM »

Thanks for the reply DJT, much appreciated

The tank is on the purpose built Fluval Roma cabinet, the cannister would be inside and the tubes out the back and up between the back of the tank and the wall which is about 5.5cm.

Not fully stocked yet but I will have 6 Sterbai Cory's, 6 Conga Tetra's, 6 Pearl Danio's, 10 Glowlight Danio's and 10 Cardinal tetra's. My question wasn't so much about overkill on flow, more that if I didn't increase the stock, would there be any point in getting the external at all and if I did would it look overcrowded.

Sue · « **Reply #3 on:** October 27, 2014, 01:31:48 PM »

Externals do allow more stock simply on the grounds that they don't displace water inside the tank. And they contain so much more media than internals.

I don't have any externals. But from what I read, the main causes of leaks are failure to re-attach the top properly after cleaning, and perishing of the seals due to lack of proper maintenance. The seals do need to be lubricated, but I don't know what with

I have heard of people who stand their externals in a bucket or bowl to catch any leakage

Wild Rover · « **Reply #4 on:** October 27, 2014, 05:10:21 PM »

Cheers Sue

I've decided to go for the external. My U4 is nearing the end of fish in cycling (ammonia 0, nitrite .5, nitrate 10) and was wondering when to switch. Would you run both together leaving all of the filter media in the U4, run both with some of the media in each or just run the external with all of the media transferred from the U4?

And would you do it now or wait until the U4 is fully cycled?

Thanks

Sue · « **Reply #5 on:** October 27, 2014, 07:01:56 PM »

Swap as soon as you have a new filter. And put all of the media into the external, some in each tray. The bacteria will colonise the new media better if they are in physical contact.
Keep an eye on your water as it is possible you will lose some bacteria during the transfer - though i don't need to tell you that

You may find your ammonia and/or nitrite will go up for a few days, but if they do it shouldn't last long.

Wild Rover · « **Reply #6 on:** October 27, 2014, 07:20:02 PM »

Thanks again Sue

Subject - Started by	Replies	Last post
Supplementary Internal filter Started by Mark64 Fishtank Filtration and Cycling	4 Replies 11604 Views	October 10, 2012, 09:38:47 PM by Mark64
Fluval power 3 internal filter? Started by hobo Fish Tanks and Equipment	3 Replies 9119 Views	June 19, 2013, 02:29:44 PM by Sue
Internal filter too strong Started by AndreaC General Fishkeeping advice	9 Replies 11960 Views	July 11, 2016, 10:48:20 AM by ColinB
Interpet Fish Pod 120L with CF3 Internal Cartridge Filter - Independent Review Started by Extreme_One Fish Tank Reviews	0 Replies 24264 Views	May 21, 2015, 08:02:10 PM by Extreme_One
Internal corner filter - any opinions? Started by fcmf Fishtank Filtration and Cycling	10 Replies 10040 Views	November 24, 2016, 09:30:40 PM by fcmf
External filter intake and tiny shrimp Started by Littlefish Fish Tanks and Equipment	4 Replies 8224 Views	February 21, 2019, 07:01:21 PM by Littlefish
External vs internal filter Started by barneyadi « 1 2 3 » Fish Tanks and Equipment	41 Replies 24140 Views	December 21, 2019, 09:15:21 PM by barneyadi

Internal Or External Filter In A Tank?

Internal Or External Filter In A Tank?

Author Topic: Internal or External Filter in A Tank? (Read 11059 times) 6 replies

Wild Rover

Internal or External Filter in A Tank?

daniel_james_taylor

Re: Internal or External?

Wild Rover

Re: Internal or External?

Sue

Re: Internal or External?

Wild Rover

Re: Internal or External?

Sue

Re: Internal or External?

Wild Rover

Re: Internal or External?

Assess Tankmates In The Tropical Fish Community Creator

Topics that relate to "Internal or External Filter in A Tank?"

Tropical Fish Keeping Help and Advice

Tropical Fish Keeping Help and Advice

Tropical Fish Keeping Product Reviews

Tropical Fish Market Place

Tropical Fish Keeping Community